Friday, March 11th, 2011
The University of Illinois released last week a publication entitled “Alternative 2011 Corn Production, Consumption and Price Scenarios” that we believe is a good read for those trying to get a handle — or at least a starting point — in looking at what may transpire in the U.S. corn market. The publication by Drs. Darrel Good and Scott Irwin takes a look at the forces shaping both supply and demand over the coming year. Some highlights are:
* A thorough discussion of 2011 yield scenarios. The authors use a long-term yield based on data since 1960. That trend provides an estimate of 158.4 bushels/acre for 2011. Good and Irwin use 158 in their supply and demand forecasts. They point out that theshorter-term (some back only as far as 1996) yield trends being used by some analysts result in yield estimates that are about 3 bushels/acre higher than those used in the paper. Good and Irwin argue that these more optimistic trends are not actually a new trend but are simply due to “ . . . adverse weather being experienced less frequently since the mid-1990s . . “
* Good and Irwin demonstrate yield variability and derive their “good weather” and “bad weather” yields by detrending the historical yield data so that past years, in essence, reflect 2011 technology. They accomplish this by adding the trending yield gain of 1.89 bushels per acre per year to each lagged year yield. The resulting chart appears on http://www.dailylivstockreport.com and clearly delineates the deviations of actual yield from trend yield in past years.
Good and Irwin throw out the low yields of 1988 and 1993 from their “bad weather” scenario computations, arguing that the 1993 flood year was a clear anomaly and that the 1988 drought was already developing by March of the year and represented conditions that are not in place at present. Based on these calculations, they choose good and bad weather yields of 169 and 147 bushels/acre, respectively.
* Good and Irwin assume that 92 million acres will be planted to corn this year — a number on the high side of some early forecasts. That planted acreage would imply 84.9 million harvested acres.
* Trend yield of 158 bushels/acre would mean the 2011 crop would be 13.414 billion bushels and total supply would be 14.1 billion bushels — down 0.75 billion from the current crop year. The good weather yield (169 bu/A) would give us a 14.35 billion bushel crop and just over 15 billion in total supply, 860 million bushels more than this year. The poor weather yield of 147 bu./A would mean only 12.48 billion bushels harvested and only
13.176 billion of total supply — 1 billion fewer bushels than this year.
* Good and Irwin provide a thorough discussion of factors that will determine corn usage in the coming year. They point out that exports and non-ethanol industrial (primarily high-fructose corn syrup) usage do not generally change much in response to corn prices.
Feed demand is more responsive to corn price but strong livestock prices imply strong feed demand in the coming year. Oil, gasoline and ethanol prices imply very strong corn demand as well. Good and Irwin include “shut-down” corn prices for ethanol plants at various oil and gasoline prices. They estimate the shut-down corn price to be $9.78/bushel at $110/bbl oil and $3/gal wholesale gasoline — prices that are very close to recent levels.
* Good and Irwin forecast an average U.S. farm corn price at $5.75/bu. for trend yield, $4.75/bu. for good weather and $7.00/bu. for poor weather. None of those prices will slow ethanol output if oil and gasoline remain near today’s levels. Good and Irwin’s balance sheets for 2010-11 and 2011-12 for the various scenarios appears on page 2. The entire report can be found at http://farmdoc.illinois.edu/marketing/mobr/mobr_11-01/mobr_11-01.html .
The Daily Livestock Report by Steve Meyer and Len Steiner